FB Twitter

Smithy Cottage

Smithy Cottage

4.2
out of 5
Ratings from 11 reviews
91% of guests
recommend
Cleanliness
4.1
Comfort
4.5
Condition
4.0
Location
4.6
Value
4.2
Customer
Service
4.1


Nestled in a quiet corner just below the swimming pool, Smithy Cottage offers a delightful retreat for up to six guests, perfect for families or groups looking to unwind.

Step inside to discover a spacious open-plan living area that seamlessly combines comfort and functionality. The fully equipped kitchen features a dining table and chairs, while the cosy seating area invites you to relax with loved ones. Enjoy your favourite shows on the smart TV or bask in the warmth of the coal-effect electric fire during those cooler evenings.

The light-filled master bedroom is a serene escape, complete with a king-size bed and an ensuite bathroom for your convenience. A second bedroom offers twin single beds, while the third bedroom features a single guest bed and a small pull-out bed, perfect for a child.

A charming path leads you through a private, sheltered garden adorned with a table and chairs, providing an idyllic space to savour morning coffee or evening meals al fresco. Smithy Cottage is your gateway to relaxation and adventure, offering a tranquil haven in the heart of the Cornish countryside.

Clean and comfortable we will be back.

Review submitted on Sun, 01 Nov 2026
4.3
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Condition
5.0
Location
3.0
Value
3.0
Customer
Service
5.0
On arrival cottage was lovely and clean. THE GAMES ROOM WAS WELL USED BY THE WHOLE FAMILY. we hope to be back again next year.

Cm from Mullionj stayed at Smithy Cottage for 7 nights in October 2026


Unkempt

Review submitted on Mon, 05 Oct 2026
2.5
out of 5

Guest doesn't recommend this property
Cleanliness
2.0
Comfort
3.0
Condition
2.0
Location
5.0
Value
2.0
Customer
Service
1.0
We stayed at this cottage, 1st of all, we arrived when it was dark, it took a while to find it as it was in a very dark secluded spot. It should have had some sort of lighting to guide us.
Secondly it was dirty, dead flies everywhere, cobwebs, the carpets had stains and the windows were filthy.
The beds where ok, but the seating was completely worn out and needs replacing. The laundry shed had good machines, but the cleaners left the machine drawers were left clogged up with old soap powder and softener.
I had to take the drawers back to our cottage to wash them before they could be used. This place needs an onsite manager to run the place, to look after it and replace worn or broken items and oversee staff.


Christine from London stayed at Smithy Cottage for 7 nights in September 2026


Disappointed

Review submitted on Wed, 30 Sep 2026
2.0
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
1.0
Comfort
2.0
Condition
2.0
Location
4.0
Value
2.0
Customer
Service
1.0
Ewell come to Mullion a few times a year and spotted the cottages in June.
We booked two weeks, paid up but needed to amend something. I sent many emails and rang a couple of times.
When I did get through, a very upset person explained that they had just lost a family member and that her grandmother had had a fall. I did apologise for her loss.
When we arrived, it was pitch dark, no lighting.
The cottage seemed OK, but after a couple of hours, noticed that the seating was knackered and uncomfortable.
The beds were ok but the pillows were flat,so we had to go out the next day to buy some.
The cottage was full of cobwebs and spiders. The windows at the front were filthy. The garden area was very untidy.
Some came to mow it with absolutely no interest,we were chatting outside and he worked around us without any acknowledgement (rude).
There was no welcome or in fact anyone who ran the place on site. Except for the cleaners two days a week and they recked the laundry shed. They left powder clogged into the soap trays and all over the floor. There is no interest.
I had to wash the soap trays in the washing machines, and had to put 2 machines on self clean. The cottages are not cheap, but they do need to be maintained by an onsite staff member.
I know that the lady that passed was the owner and lived her little cottages and guests. Let's hope whoever takes over has the same passion. All the cottages need is a inspection and replace faulty equipment.


Christine from London stayed at Smithy Cottage for 7 nights in September 2026


Good value cottage

Review submitted on Thu, 03 Sep 2026
3.7
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
3.0
Comfort
4.0
Condition
3.0
Location
4.0
Value
4.0
Customer
Service
4.0
My family enjoyed staying for a week and the communication was great. The cottage decor and equipment (play room) was a bit tired but the kids enjoyed it and we had a lovely holiday overall. The pool was a great bonus and location excellent for visiting nearby beaches. Overall I’d recommend given the more competitive price compared to other cottages in the area.

David from London stayed at Smithy Cottage for 7 nights in August 2026


Wonderful Cottage

Review submitted on Sun, 16 Aug 2026
4.8
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Condition
5.0
Location
5.0
Value
5.0
Customer
Service
4.0
We love coming here for our holiday with all our family. It is in an excellent location, is good value for money and we enjoy the swimming pool, and leisure facilities as well as the close proximity to the beaches.

Elizabeth from Marlborough stayed at Smithy Cottage for 14 nights in July 2026


Great place to stay

Review submitted on Sun, 05 Jul 2026
5.0
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Condition
5.0
Location
5.0
Value
5.0
Customer
Service
5.0
We love holidaying at trenance vey peaceful and surrounded by the most beautiful scenery. Our happy place.

Denise from Greater Manchester stayed at Smithy Cottage for 14 nights in June 2026


Early Summer Trenance

Review submitted on Wed, 03 Jun 2026
4.8
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Condition
4.0
Location
5.0
Value
5.0
Customer
Service
5.0
Beautiful and comfortable stay on the Lizard. Our Smithy cottage is private and has all the requirements needed.

David from Desborough stayed at Smithy Cottage for 7 nights in May 2026


Caja replied 165 days ago
Thank you for your lovely review. We're delighted to hear you had a beautiful and comfortable stay at Smithy Cottage. It's great to know you enjoyed the privacy of the cottage and found everything you needed during your visit. We look forward to welcoming you back to Trenance Farm Cottages again soon for another relaxing stay on the Lizard Peninsula.

A great location and lovely cottage

Review submitted on Mon, 03 Nov 2025
4.7
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
4.0
Comfort
5.0
Condition
4.0
Location
5.0
Value
5.0
Customer
Service
5.0
We had a great stay. Rooms were clean and tidy and perfect for our family. The welcome pack was very much appreciated. Great location too

Lucy from Calton stayed at Smithy Cottage for 7 nights in October 2025


Caja replied more than 1 year ago
Thank you so much for your lovely feedback! We’re delighted to hear you had a great stay and found the cottage clean, comfortable, and ideal for your family. It’s great to know you enjoyed the welcome pack and our convenient location too. We hope to welcome you back to Trenance Farm Cottages again soon!

2 week stay

Review submitted on Wed, 13 Aug 2025
4.8
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Condition
4.0
Location
5.0
Value
5.0
Customer
Service
5.0
We have stayed here on many occasions. It is in a lovely location and very suitable for a family meet up. Just a slight smell of damp in the cupboard under the sink this year.

Elizabeth from Marlborough stayed at Smithy Cottage for 14 nights in July 2025


Caja replied more than 1 year ago
Thank you for choosing to stay with us again – it’s always lovely to welcome back familiar faces. We’re so pleased you enjoyed the location and found it a great spot for your family meet-up. I appreciate you letting us know about the slight smell in the cupboard under the sink. We’ll make sure to look into this promptly so it’s fresh for the next guest. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon.

As always a great stay

Review submitted on Mon, 31 Mar 2025
5.0
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Condition
5.0
Location
5.0
Value
5.0
Customer
Service
5.0
We have been going every year for many years and had a lovely week's stay and were well looked after by Tamara and her team. Nothing is too much trouble and she is always on hand to cater to your needs. The location is ideal for touring either the north or south coast of West Cornwall, or just relaxing in your own little bit of cottage garden enjoying the sun with a coffee. Local shops are nearby for all your needs and Sunday roast at The Mounts Bay Inn is well worth a visit.

Terry from Maidenhead stayed at Smithy Cottage for 7 nights in March 2025


Caja Tyler-Street replied more than 1 year ago
Thank you so much for your kind words! We absolutely love having you return each year—it’s always a pleasure to make sure you have a wonderful stay. We look forward to welcoming you back for more relaxing or exploring in beautiful West Cornwall!

New Home Hunting

Review submitted on Tue, 11 Feb 2025
5.0
out of 5

Guest recommends this property
Cleanliness
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Condition
5.0
Location
5.0
Value
5.0
Customer
Service
5.0
I have stayed in the Cottages at Trenance Farm on a number of occasions and during all times of the year. I have always found the cottages, of which i have stayed in pretty much all, to be clean, comfortable, well appointed and located in a fantastic location. My son now lives and works in Cornwall and it is an excellent place to stay and enjoy home style comforts whilst catching up with him. I would thoroughly recommend a stay here. The prices are good value and definitely worth a visit. Staff at the location are also friendly, helpful and on hand should you require them

Paula from Rugby Warwickshire stayed at Smithy Cottage for 7 nights in February 2025


Caja Tyler-Street replied more than 1 year ago
Thank you so much for your wonderful review and for being such a loyal guest! It’s great to hear that our cottages have been the perfect home-away-from-home for catching up with your son. We’re so glad to know that you’ve always had a comfortable stay, and we truly appreciate your kind words about the location and our team. We look forward to welcoming you back on your next visit to Cornwall!